3-2-1 Spring Carnival Comp - Racing Talk - Racehorse TALK harm-plan

Racehorse TALK



3-2-1 Spring Carnival Comp - Racing Talk - Racehorse TALK

Author Topic: 3-2-1 Spring Carnival Comp  (Read 11400 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline JWesleyHarding

  • Group 1
  • User 231
  • Posts: 18248
« 2018-Aug-25, 09:32 AM Reply #25 »


SR5#8 Neutrality
SR6#3 Danawi
SR7#9  Avilius
MR8#1 Hey Doc





Online wily ole dog

  • Group 1
  • User 218
  • Posts: 25632
« 2018-Aug-25, 09:39 AM Reply #26 »
SR5 #9 Ringerdingding
SR6 #11 ontnetake
SR7 #3 Emperor's Way
MR8 # Mr Sneaky

Thanks PP 8-)

Offline ratsack

  • VIP Club
  • Group 1
  • User 327
  • Posts: 10310
« 2018-Aug-25, 10:13 AM Reply #27 »
SR5 #3 Jonker
SR6 #3 Danawi
SR7 #1 Auvray
MR8 #9 Bandipur

Offline Spudda028

  • Group 2
  • User 199
  • Posts: 4862
« 2018-Aug-25, 10:40 AM Reply #28 »
SR5 #8 Neutrality
SR6 #11 Onthetake
SR7 #16 Salsonic
MR8 #5 Faatinah

Offline sobig

  • Group 2
  • User 583
  • Posts: 3451
« 2018-Aug-25, 10:49 AM Reply #29 »
SR5 #1 Performer
SR6 #1 Outrageous
SR7 #9 Avilius
MR8 #1 Hey Doc

Offline turfdeli

  • Group3
  • User 587
  • Posts: 821
« 2018-Aug-25, 11:15 AM Reply #30 »
SR5 #5 PLAGUE STONE
SR6 #11 ONTHETAKE
SR7 #9 AVILIUS
MR8 #3 QUILISTA

Offline Racehorses

  • VIP Club
  • Group 2
  • User 227
  • Posts: 3576
« 2018-Aug-25, 12:09 PM Reply #31 »
SR5 #7 Tchaikousky
SR6 #8 Cloak
SR7 #13 I am Serious
MR8 #11 Super Too

Offline Gintara

  • Group 1
  • User 16
  • Posts: 12209
« 2018-Aug-25, 12:40 PM Reply #32 »
SR5#5 Plague Stone
SR6#3 Danawi
SR7#9  Avilius
MR8#3 Quilista

Offline westie

  • Group 1
  • User 8
  • Posts: 14190
« 2018-Aug-25, 01:13 PM Reply #33 »
Testing the reply function.

wily pointed out you couldn't reply.  The topic was locked - probably one of the mods with fat thumbs and probably me  :shy:

Unlocked now.
PP7
That was nice of you, however I believe it was probably me as I thought I clicked on sticky last evening inorder to keep the thread at the top.

Offline westie

  • Group 1
  • User 8
  • Posts: 14190
« 2018-Aug-25, 01:17 PM Reply #34 »
SR5#1 Performer
SR6#3 Danawi
SR7#13 I Am Serious
MR8#1 Hey Doc

Offline JWesleyHarding

  • Group 1
  • User 231
  • Posts: 18248
« 2018-Aug-25, 02:07 PM Reply #35 »
PP

Sobig doesn't appear to have received credit for Siege of Quebec last week.

Which would make him a leader of the comp.


Offline PoisonPen7

  • Group 1
  • User 55
  • Posts: 20286
« 2018-Aug-25, 02:14 PM Reply #36 »
PP

Sobig doesn't appear to have received credit for Siege of Quebec last week.

Which would make him a leader of the comp.

Thanks. Those are the sorts of things I need pointed out as the allocation of points is manual and prone to error  :shy:

New table:

Player 18/08/18 TOTAL RANK
Brian Mc 6 6 6
Gintara 8 8 3
JWesleyHarding 9 9 1
PoisonPen7 5 5 8
Racehorses 0 0 11
Spudda028 6 6 6
Willy18 0 0 11
ratsack 8 8 3
sobig 9 9 1
specialweek2 7 7 5
turfdeli 3 3 10
wily ole dog 5 5 8

Results for last week updated

Brian Mc MR7 #13 Grunt 0
Gintara MR7 #2 Black Heart Bart 0
JWesleyHarding MR7 #13 Grunt 0
PoisonPen7 MR7 #1 Hartnell 2
Racehorses MR7 # 3 Humidor 0
Spudda028 MR7 #9 Widgee Turf 1
Willy18 MR7 #16 Miss Gunpowder 0
ratsack MR7 #5 Danon Liberty 0
sobig MR7 #14 Showtime 3
specialweek2 MR7 #14 Showtime 3
turfdeli MR7 #2 BLACK HEART BART 0
wily ole dog MR7 #12 Mighty Boss 0
Brian Mc SR4 #3 Oohood 0
Gintara SR4 #1 Fiesta 3
JWesleyHarding SR4 #1 Fiesta 3
PoisonPen7 SR4 #3 Oohood 0
Racehorses SR4 # 9 Ready To Prophet 0
Spudda028 SR4 #7 Oohod 0
Willy18 SR4 #7 Laburnum 0
ratsack SR4 #1 Fiesta 3
sobig SR4 #6 Futooh 1
specialweek2 SR4 #6 Futooh 1
turfdeli SR4 #3 OOHOOD 0
wily ole dog SR4 #1 Fiesta 3
Brian Mc SR7 #1 Le Romain 3
Gintara SR7 #7 Siege of Quebec 2
JWesleyHarding SR7 #1 Le Romain 3
PoisonPen7 SR7 #1 Le Romain 3
Racehorses SR7 # 9 Condor Heroes 0
Spudda028 SR7 #7 Siege of QueBec 2
Willy18 SR7 #11 Radiant choice 0
ratsack SR7 #1 Le Romain 3
sobig SR7 #7 Siege of Quebec 2
specialweek2 SR7 #1 Le Romain 3
turfdeli SR7 #1 LE ROMAIN 3
wily ole dog SR7 #6 No Doubt 0
Brian Mc SR8 #1 Egyptian Symbol 3
Gintara SR8 #1 Egyptian Symbol 3
JWesleyHarding SR8 #1 Egyptian Symbol 3
PoisonPen7 SR8 #2 I Am Coldplay 0
Racehorses SR8 # 9 Sharpness 0
Spudda028 SR8 #1 Egyptian SymBol 3
Willy18 SR8 #5 Luvaluva 0
ratsack SR8 #3 Zestful 2
sobig SR8 #1 Egyptian Symbol 3
specialweek2 SR8 #5 Luvaluva 0
turfdeli SR8 #10 SMART AMELIA 0
wily ole dog SR8 #3 Zestful 2

Offline sobig

  • Group 2
  • User 583
  • Posts: 3451
« 2018-Aug-25, 02:15 PM Reply #37 »
I think you are correct jwh.

Online wily ole dog

  • Group 1
  • User 218
  • Posts: 25632
« 2018-Aug-25, 02:20 PM Reply #38 »
I hope the leader bias is reversed by the time Mr Sneaky races otherwise those of you on Quilista are on a moral :bleh:

Offline PoisonPen7

  • Group 1
  • User 55
  • Posts: 20286
« 2018-Aug-25, 02:24 PM Reply #39 »
With the San Domenico coming up soon these are the tips thus far:

Brian Mc MR8 #1 Hey Doc
Gintara MR8 #3 Quilista
JWesleyHarding MR8 #1 Hey Doc
PoisonPen7 MR8 #3 Quilista
Racehorses MR8 #11 Super Too
Spudda028 MR8 #5 Faatinah
ratsack MR8 #9 Bandipur
sobig MR8 #1 Hey Doc
specialweek2 MR8 #5 Faatinah
turfdeli MR8 #3 QUILISTA
westie MR8 #1 Hey Doc
wily ole dog MR8 # Mr Sneaky
Brian Mc SR5 #3 Jonker
Gintara SR5 #5 Plague Stone
JWesleyHarding SR5 #8 Neutrality
PoisonPen7 SR5 #3 Jonker
Racehorses SR5 #7 Tchaikousky
Spudda028 SR5 #8 Neutrality
ratsack SR5 #3 Jonker
sobig SR5 #1 Performer
specialweek2 SR5 #1 Performer
turfdeli SR5 #5 PLAGUE STONE
westie SR5 #1 Performer
wily ole dog SR5 #9 Ringerdingding
Brian Mc SR6 #5 Aramayo
Gintara SR6 #3 Danawi
JWesleyHarding SR6 #3 Danawi
PoisonPen7 SR6 #4 Exceltic
Racehorses SR6 #8 Cloak
Spudda028 SR6 #11 Onthetake
ratsack SR6 #3 Danawi
sobig SR6 #1 Outrageous
specialweek2 SR6 #1 Outrageous
turfdeli SR6 #11 ONTHETAKE
westie SR6 #3 Danawi
wily ole dog SR6 #11 ontnetake
Brian Mc SR7 #9 Avilius
Gintara SR7 #9 Avilius
JWesleyHarding SR7 #9 Avilius
PoisonPen7 SR7 #9 Avilius
Racehorses SR7 #13 I am Serious
Spudda028 SR7 #16 Salsonic
ratsack SR7 #1 Auvray
sobig SR7 #9 Avilius
specialweek2 SR7 #9 Avilius
turfdeli SR7 #9 AVILIUS
westie SR7 #13 I Am Serious
wily ole dog SR7 #3 Emperor's Way

Offline PoisonPen7

  • Group 1
  • User 55
  • Posts: 20286
« 2018-Aug-25, 02:33 PM Reply #40 »
No-one picked Graff!!

Online wily ole dog

  • Group 1
  • User 218
  • Posts: 25632
« 2018-Aug-25, 02:52 PM Reply #41 »
Krisís lees declared it the best colt heís ever had :o

Offline PoisonPen7

  • Group 1
  • User 55
  • Posts: 20286
« 2018-Aug-25, 06:25 PM Reply #42 »
Please let me know if I have made a mistake here. Thanks.

Brian Mc MR8 #1 Hey Doc 0
Gintara MR8 #3 Quilista 0
JWesleyHarding MR8 #1 Hey Doc 0
PoisonPen7 MR8 #3 Quilista 0
Racehorses MR8 #11 Super Too 0
Spudda028 MR8 #5 Faatinah 3
ratsack MR8 #9 Bandipur 0
sobig MR8 #1 Hey Doc 0
specialweek2 MR8 #5 Faatinah 3
turfdeli MR8 #3 QUILISTA 0
westie MR8 #1 Hey Doc 0
wily ole dog MR8 #8 Mr Sneaky 1
Brian Mc SR5 #3 Jonker 0
Gintara SR5 #5 Plague Stone 0
JWesleyHarding SR5 #8 Neutrality 2
PoisonPen7 SR5 #3 Jonker 0
Racehorses SR5 #7 Tchaikousky 0
Spudda028 SR5 #8 Neutrality 2
ratsack SR5 #3 Jonker 0
sobig SR5 #1 Performer 1
specialweek2 SR5 #1 Performer 1
turfdeli SR5 #5 PLAGUE STONE 0
westie SR5 #1 Performer 1
wily ole dog SR5 #9 Ringerdingding 0
Brian Mc SR6 #5 Aramayo 0
Gintara SR6 #3 Danawi 3
JWesleyHarding SR6 #3 Danawi 3
PoisonPen7 SR6 #4 Exceltic 0
Racehorses SR6 #8 Cloak 0
Spudda028 SR6 #11 Onthetake 0
ratsack SR6 #3 Danawi 3
sobig SR6 #1 Outrageous 0
specialweek2 SR6 #1 Outrageous 0
turfdeli SR6 #11 ONTHETAKE 0
westie SR6 #3 Danawi 3
wily ole dog SR6 #11 ontnetake 0
Brian Mc SR7 #9 Avilius 3
Gintara SR7 #9 Avilius 3
JWesleyHarding SR7 #9 Avilius 3
PoisonPen7 SR7 #9 Avilius 3
Racehorses SR7 #13 I am Serious 2
Spudda028 SR7 #16 Salsonic 0
ratsack SR7 #1 Auvray 0
sobig SR7 #9 Avilius 3
specialweek2 SR7 #9 Avilius 3
turfdeli SR7 #9 AVILIUS 3
westie SR7 #13 I Am Serious 2
wily ole dog SR7 #3 Emperor's Way 0

Offline PoisonPen7

  • Group 1
  • User 55
  • Posts: 20286
« 2018-Aug-25, 06:34 PM Reply #43 »
If the above is correct then this is the updated table:

Player 18/08/18 25/08/18 TOTAL RANK
Brian Mc 6 3 9 7
Gintara 8 6 14 2
JWesleyHarding 9 8 17 1
PoisonPen7 5 3 8 8
Racehorses 0 2 2 12
Spudda028 6 5 11 5
Willy18 0 0 0 13
ratsack 8 3 11 5
sobig 9 4 13 4
specialweek2 7 7 14 2
turfdeli 3 3 6 9
wily ole dog 5 1 6 9
westie 0 6 6 9

Offline fours

  • Group 1
  • User 704
  • Posts: 5386
« 2018-Aug-25, 09:58 PM Reply #44 »
Hmmm,

Disgree with forced race picks.

It's a bad habit. Bad habits are the undoing of many people.

Better to only tip/look where you have a perceived advantage...... just like the gamblers song.

Gotta run.... :dry:

Fours

Offline Gintara

  • Group 1
  • User 16
  • Posts: 12209
« 2018-Aug-25, 11:23 PM Reply #45 »
Hmmm,

Disgree with forced race picks.

It's a bad habit. Bad habits are the undoing of many people.

Better to only tip/look where you have a perceived advantage...... just like the gamblers song.

Gotta run.... :dry:

Fours

To counter that, price isn't a factor here so the perceived edge you rabbit on about is irrelevant. Just find the winner  :whistle:

Offline fours

  • Group 1
  • User 704
  • Posts: 5386
« 2018-Aug-26, 04:49 AM Reply #46 »
Gintara and all,

Not everyone gets this but a large part of successful gambling is a psychological edge.

"Just find the winner" is a bad psychological approach. I am not talking the bad maths of finding more winners than anyone else but showing a loss on returns overall; clear Peter Mair psychological comfort area of fiscal ruin by the way.

If you cant see it than you cant see it. I wont rabbit on about it BUT this very thing is what separates the wheat from the chaff.

Fours

Online wily ole dog

  • Group 1
  • User 218
  • Posts: 25632
« 2018-Aug-26, 08:44 AM Reply #47 »
Fours
I understand your thoughts but I wanted to do something different to the TAB comp which will start soon.

PP does a great job of posting race fields that he finds intetesting for this forum so I decided to attempt to extend that effort and interest.

We need to be flexible in our thoughts and Iíve failed to adapt. So far Iíve dropped tips that were obvious and doing my usual by picking roughies.
Pretty stupid in a 3-2-1 comp  :lol:

It highlights your point of thinking before putting your hand in your pocket

Offline fours

  • Group 1
  • User 704
  • Posts: 5386
« 2018-Aug-26, 09:08 AM Reply #48 »
wily ole dog,

I am far from perfect ( jfc can elucidate ) but I have taken some strides down the psychological edge road.

Not participating in a 3 2 1 comp is a part of that.. Simply put who ever tips the most favourites is likely to win and the longer the comp goes the more certain this is.

Accordingly it loses a lot of interest for those with a grasp of the numbers in this game.

Does not mean some will enjoy the exercise but to each their own.

Fours

Offline PoisonPen7

  • Group 1
  • User 55
  • Posts: 20286
« 2018-Aug-26, 10:00 AM Reply #49 »
Fours,

To quote Oscar Wilde you appear to be a man who "knows the price of everything and the value of nothing".

We are just having a bit of fun on a Saturday.......


BACK TO ALL TOPICS
Sitemap