Manuel was in worst at the weights on your table of the handicappers score by a very big margin of -8.5........
Have you thrown the handicap book out as it was a very good win.
Of course a fitter Kementari would have ran straight past him but that's too late for the day.
My metrics are taken from the handicapper's benchmark rating
not my own so I cannot throw anything out
Just something I like measuring i.e. what weight would they carry if it was a benchmark handicap and how much better/worse off are they because it is WFA.
The way they calculate the handicaps in a BM race using the BM rating is available on the Racing NSW web site.
The horse had a low benchmark rating because his best city effort prior to his Group 1 win was a 2nd place in a Benchmark 96 race. And that is probably why he was such big odds.