Disagree PP in regards to Reynolds being the best kicker. I think Cleary at the moment is the best half with everything including his kicking game. Reynolds will be 2nd but 1st on longevity. Hughes is catching upto Reynolds but does not have the same control as Reynolds.
For me Souths are dumb to lose a halfback as good as Reynolds but only time will tell regrading Reynolds. Not that many halfbacks win NRL GF in their 30s. Those that do like Cronk, Thurston, Langer etc are usually amongst the great halfbacks of all time. Is Reynolds that good?